Not Your Average Sparkle: 7 Alternative Engagement Rings For Non-Traditional Brides

Looking for an engagement ring that actually feels like you? Whether you're vibing with dark elegance, modern minimalism, or dreamy gemstones, we've got just the thing. At Love & Promise, we believe your engagement ring should tell your love story – not someone else's Pinterest board.

Ready to break tradition and fall in love with something refreshingly you? Here are 7 of our favorite alternative engagement rings that are anything but ordinary. Let’s dive in!

Black Onyx Velma

Bold, mysterious and magic all around! Looking for a black stone engagement ring that turns heads? Our black onyx Velma brings major drama in the best way possible. She stuns with a striking 14x7mm black onyx center stone resting atop a glittering gold diamond band, plus a secret hidden halo of diamonds for that peekaboo sparkle. Gothic, glam, and full of main character energy!

Black Onyx & Diamond Velma Ring

Aeryn

The minimalist muse with a unique twist! Meet Aeryn, a solitaire...but not like the others! This sleek beauty features an 8x6mm emerald cut moissanite in a semi-bezel, east west setting - aka, unexpected perfection. She’s low key luxe and effortlessly cool. For those who love clean lines, modern edges, and a little rule-breaking romance, Aeryn is your girl!

Aeryn Moissanite Engagement Ring

Miriam

Who says wedding bands can’t be engagement rings? We’re here to say it loud: there are no rules! That’s why our Miriam wedding band absolutely doubles as an engagement ring. Choose from bezel set emerald cut moissanites or lab-grown diamonds for a modern, edgy look that’s perfect for stacking...or shining solo!

Miriam Wedding Ring

3.17ct Gemini

A match made in gemstone heaven! She’s the ultimate toi et moi ring, and we're obsessed. Our 3.17ct Gemini pairs an icy cornflower blue radiant sapphire with a rich ocean teal pear sapphire. Together, they tell a story of balance, duality, and heart-fluttering beauty.

3.17ct Gemini Sapphire Toi Et Moi Ring

Effie

Say hello to Effie – our effortlessly chic ring that redefines what “alternative” can look like. Her 10x5mm marquise center stone is surrounded by a unique half halo of diamonds and an asymmetrical side stone. Artsy, unexpected, and totally swoon-worthy!

Effie Moissanite & Diamond Engagement Ring

0.92ct Astrid

Modern, sparkly and sustainable stunning. Our Astrid ring is here for all the eco-conscious lovers with an eye for sparkle! Featuring a 0.92ct marquise cut lab diamond and a dazzling arrangement of side stones, this ring gives drama with a conscience. Ethical never looked so good!

0.92ct Astrid Lab Diamond Ring

1.77ct Geneva

Calling all gemstone lovers and whimsical souls! The 1.77ct Geneva is all about soft cornflower lavender hues and petal-like diamond accents. Her sapphire center is flanked by marquise diamonds arranged like scattered flower petals. A blooming beauty in every sense!

1.77ct Geneva Sapphire & Diamond Ring

Customization

Want to create your own one of a kind alternative engagement ring? We can bring your ring dream to life through our custom design process! Feel free to contact us or schedule an appointment - we can’t wait to hear from you!

How fun was this alternative engagement ring guide? As always, be sure to follow us on our socials, check out our website and subscribe to our newsletter to see what’s new here at Love & Promise. Catch you next time, friends!